AITA for cutting contact with my entire family after discovering they held secret meetings about putting me under guardianship?

Gather 'round, folks, because today's AITA submission is a masterclass in family drama, betrayal, and the painful lines we draw when our trust is shattered. Our anonymous poster, let's call them 'GuardianAngel,' brings us a story that will make your jaw drop and your blood boil. It’s a stark reminder that sometimes the people closest to us can inflict the deepest wounds, all under the guise of 'caring.'

This isn't just about a disagreement over holiday plans; this is about autonomy, respect, and the fundamental right to make your own life choices. Imagine waking up to find out your loved ones have been plotting behind your back to seize control of your life. It's a scenario straight out of a psychological thriller, but unfortunately for GuardianAngel, it was their stark reality. Let's dive into the details.

"AITA for cutting contact with my entire family after discovering they held secret meetings about putting me under guardianship?"

This case is a heart-wrenching example of the clash between perceived parental concern and an adult child's fundamental right to autonomy. On one hand, one could argue that the family, seeing a loved one struggle with a chronic illness, might genuinely believe they are acting out of love and a desire to protect. Their intentions, however misguided, could stem from a place of deep worry, especially if they exaggerate the severity of the OP's condition in their minds.

However, the absolute secrecy surrounding these meetings is where their actions cross a significant line. To discuss, and actively pursue, legal guardianship without first having an open, honest conversation with the individual in question is a profound breach of trust and respect. It strips the OP of their agency and treats them as an object to be managed, rather than a capable adult with rights and a voice.

The family's excuses about not wanting to 'stress' or 'upset' the OP ring hollow when compared to the magnitude of what they were attempting to do. A conservatorship is an extreme legal measure, typically reserved for individuals who are demonstrably unable to care for themselves or make sound decisions. The fact that the OP maintains a job, lives independently, and manages their own care seriously undermines any claim of incapacitation.

Therefore, the OP's reaction, while severe, is entirely understandable. The discovery isn't just a disagreement; it's a fundamental betrayal that redefines the entire family dynamic. Cutting contact, in this context, is not an 'overreaction' but a necessary boundary to protect their mental well-being and assert their autonomy in the face of an unprecedented assault on their independence. They are rightfully reclaiming control.

The internet weighs in: Was OP justified in severing ties?

The comment section on this post was, as expected, a firestorm of opinions, though overwhelmingly in favor of GuardianAngel. Many users shared similar stories of families overstepping boundaries or making assumptions about their competence due to illness or disability. The common thread was the feeling of profound betrayal when those closest to you undermine your autonomy.

There were strong sentiments about the importance of setting firm boundaries, especially when family members act in ways that are deeply disrespectful or harmful. Most agreed that attempting to gain guardianship behind someone's back is not 'love and concern,' but a shocking display of control that warrants a complete reevaluation of the relationship.

So, there you have it. The consensus is overwhelmingly clear: GuardianAngel is unequivocally NTA. The betrayal suffered here goes beyond a simple misunderstanding; it strikes at the very core of personal autonomy and trust. While family 'concern' can sometimes be well-intentioned, when it manifests as secret legal plotting, it transforms into an act of profound disrespect and control. GuardianAngel's decision to go no contact is not an overreaction, but a necessary step to protect their independence and mental well-being. It’s a harsh lesson for the family, but one they brought upon themselves.